Best Dupes for Setting Plaster
Setting Plaster is that flattering plaster pink that makes walls feel sunlit even on grey days. Renovators hunt for dupes when they’re painting entire apartments, cabinetry, or rental makeovers and need washable, quick-drying formulas without boutique pricing. The closest matches lean peach rather than lilac, carry a chalky base so the finish stays powdery, and keep saturation low enough to sit beside Belgian linens, travertine, and pale woods without veering sugary.
Dupes for Setting Plaster
| Brand ▲ | Colour ▲ | Rating ▲ | Shop |
|---|---|---|---|
| Benjamin Moore | Sandpiper Beige | 2 ⭐ | |
| Benjamin Moore | Georgetown Pink Beige | 2 ⭐ | |
| Little Greene | Beauvais Lilac | 2 ⭐ | |
| Dulux Trade | Soft Almond 4 | 2 ⭐ | |
| Little Greene | Regency Fawn | 2 ⭐ | |
| Dulux Trade | Crumpled Linen 1 | 2 ⭐ | |
| Benjamin Moore | Odessa Pink | 1 ⭐ | |
| Dulux Trade | Caramel Blush 4 | 1 ⭐ | |
| Dulux Trade | Caramel Blush 3 | 1 ⭐ | |
| Dulux Trade | Frayed Hessian 1 | 1 ⭐ | |
| Dulux Trade | Soft Maplewood 3 | 1 ⭐ | |
| Dulux Trade | Soft Maplewood 4 | 1 ⭐ | |
| PPG / Johnstone's | Champagne Wishes / Birthday Suit | 2 ⭐ | |
| PPG / Johnstone's | Cocoa Cream | 2 ⭐ | |
| PPG / Johnstone's | Spice Beige | 1 ⭐ | |
| PPG / Johnstone's | Cinnamon Ice | 1 ⭐ | |
| PPG / Johnstone's | Peach Brick | 1 ⭐ | |
| Behr | Artisan Tea | 3 ⭐ | |
| Behr | Elusive Dawn | 2 ⭐ | |
| Behr | Bali Sand | 2 ⭐ | |
| Behr | Tapestry Beige | 2 ⭐ | |
| Behr | Cinnamon Tea | 2 ⭐ | |
| Behr | Sand Dance | 2 ⭐ | |
| Behr | Coral Stone | 2 ⭐ | |
| Behr | Sienna Dust | 2 ⭐ | |
| Behr | One to Remember | 1 ⭐ | |
| Valspar | Alpaca Mittens | 2 ⭐ | |
| Valspar | Milk Toast | 2 ⭐ | |
| Valspar | Warm Alpaca | 2 ⭐ | |
| Valspar | Vanilla Iced Coffee | 2 ⭐ | |
| Valspar | Vanilla Iced Coffee | 2 ⭐ | |
| Valspar | Cocoa Dust | 2 ⭐ | |
| Valspar | Fresh Baked | 2 ⭐ | |
| Valspar | Cookie Dough | 2 ⭐ | |
| Valspar | Cookie Dough | 2 ⭐ | |
| Valspar | Silken Stockings | 2 ⭐ | |
| Valspar | Hopsack | 2 ⭐ | |
| Valspar | Dust Bunny | 2 ⭐ |
What makes Setting Plaster so flattering
Setting Plaster sits in that sweet spot between blush and clay. It is warm enough to flatter every skin tone yet grounded by a tiny dose of brown so it never screams “nursery pink.” In daylight it feels sun-washed, almost like aged stucco; under lamplight it deepens and wraps a room in a soft glow. Because the colour is mid-tone, it performs best on matte or estate emulsion finishes that keep the surface powdery and diffuse—sheens can make it look shiny and cheap.
Think carefully about what frames it. Off-whites such as Dimity highlight cornicing without jarring, while stone floors, travertine tiles, and pale oaks anchor the palette. If you need contrast, charcoal artwork or patinated bronze hardware will sharpen the scheme without cooling the walls down.
Testing dupes and finish options
Dupes should stay dusty rather than peach. When you sample alternatives, paint them on a primed board and sit it next to fabrics, polished plaster, or tiles you already own; Setting Plaster’s magic comes from how it bounces off texture, so you need to see the interaction in both morning and evening light. High-traffic spaces like kitchens or hallways demand scrubbable matt or eggshell finishes—look for paints that tout ceramic or scuff-resistant tech so repeated wiping doesn’t burnish the surface.
For woodwork, consider a slightly deeper tone such as Templeton Pink to create subtle definition. If you’re pairing with built-ins in Dead Salmon, keep the sheen consistent so the palette feels intentional even when mixing brands for price or durability reasons.
Where Setting Plaster excels
Bedrooms, home offices, and dining rooms benefit from its flattering glow, but it also thrives in bathrooms with limestone or tadelakt where you want a boutique-hotel feel. On cabinetry, it softens sharp joinery and pairs beautifully with unlacquered brass or cane details, while on ceilings it erases the stark line that white often creates. The trade-off is that strong daylight can wash it out in south-facing rooms—layer window dressings or use colour on adjacent walls to keep depth. Balance the scheme with tactile textiles, boucle sofas, and woven shades, and let greenery or oxidised metals deliver contrast. When styled thoughtfully, Setting Plaster reads as a sophisticated neutral rather than a trend-led pink, making it a safe choice for resale while still feeling personal.
Setting Plaster vs Similar Shades
| Compared Colour | Relationship | When to choose it instead | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pink Ground | Lighter blush | Choose when you want a whisper of pink on ceilings or open-plan walls but need maximum light bounce. | View colour |
| Templeton Pink | Dustier + moodier | Ideal for dining rooms or bedrooms where you want the same warmth with more historic depth. | View colour |
| Dead Salmon | Earthier taupe | Use on cabinetry or adjoining rooms when you want a mauve-brown accent that still complements Setting Plaster walls. | View colour |
| Dimity | Neutral partner | Great for trims and ceilings when you need a soft off-white that won’t fight the pink undertone. | View colour |
| Calamine | Rosier alternative | Swap in for nurseries or bathrooms where you want a fresher, slightly sweeter pink that still feels grown up. | View colour |